Don't miss our holiday offer - up to 50% OFF!
Withings Body+ vs RENPHO: Which Should We Buy?
Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click and purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us.
Which smart scale will actually help us hit our goals—let’s uncover the surprising features that turn numbers into real health wins.
Standing on a scale shouldn’t feel mysterious—we’ll compare the WITHINGS Body+ and RENPHO smart scales, focusing on accuracy, connectivity, features, and value, so we know exactly what matters when choosing the right smart scale for our needs and saving time.
Clinical Precision
Withings Body+ Smart Body Composition Scale
Amazon.com
We find this scale excellent for someone who wants clinical-grade tracking and a polished app experience. It consistently delivers precise weight readings, a broad set of metrics, and easy multi-user syncing for long-term trend tracking.
Budget Friendly
RENPHO Bluetooth Body Fat Smart Scale
Amazon.com
We see this as a very attractive budget option for everyday tracking and trend monitoring. It provides a broad set of metrics and easy app integration, but it won’t match clinical-grade accuracy or premium materials.
Withings Body+ Scale
RENPHO Body Scale
Withings Body+ Scale
RENPHO Body Scale
Withings Body+ Scale
RENPHO Body Scale
Smart Scales Showdown: Withings vs. Renpho — Which Is Best?
1
Product Profiles: What Each Scale Offers
We present clear, side-by-side profiles of the WITHINGS Body+ and the RENPHO Bluetooth Body Fat Scale so we understand baseline capabilities before testing accuracy and usability.
WITHINGS Body+ — Key specs & highlights
The Body+ is positioned as a premium, clinically-minded smart scale built for long-term tracking and multi-user households.
RENPHO Bluetooth Body Fat Scale — Key specs & highlights
RENPHO aims for maximum value with a compact, app-driven approach suitable for families and tight budgets.
Feature Comparison
Withings Body+ Scale vs. RENPHO Body Scale
VS
Price
$$$
VS
$
Max weight capacity
Up to 396 lbs (≈180 kg)
VS
Up to 396 lbs (≈180 kg)
Accuracy claim / Validation
Clinically validated body composition algorithms
VS
Consumer-grade BIA estimates (not clinically validated)
Connectivity
Wi‑Fi + Bluetooth
VS
Bluetooth only
App compatibility
Withings Health Mate; syncs to Apple Health, Google Fit, etc.
VS
RENPHO app; syncs to Apple Health, Samsung Health, MyFitnessPal
Metrics tracked
Weight, fat mass, muscle mass, bone mass, visceral fat index, heart rate, metabolism estimates (8+)
VS
Weight, body fat, BMI, muscle mass, bone mass, visceral fat, water, metabolic age (≈13 metrics)
Display
High-resolution color screen with on-device trend info
VS
Simple LED / LCD display
Multi-user recognition
Automatic recognition for multiple users
VS
Supports up to 20 user profiles
Special modes
Pregnancy, baby mode, athlete mode
VS
Baby/pet mode and basic athlete settings
Battery type & life
User-replaceable batteries; up to ~15 months (batteries included)
VS
AAA batteries (user-supplied); months of typical use depending on frequency
Platform / Materials
Tempered glass platform with sturdy chassis
VS
Tempered glass platform, slim profile
Auto sync
Automatic over Wi‑Fi and Bluetooth
VS
Bluetooth sync; some data requires app open
Warranty / Support
Manufacturer limited warranty; established support ecosystem
VS
Standard manufacturer support and replacement policy
2
Measurement Accuracy & Health Metrics: Which Gives Better Data?
How they measure (BIA + weight sensors)
Both scales use precise weight sensors (strain gauges) plus bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) through foot electrodes to estimate body composition. Weight measurements are inherently the most accurate metric; body-fat, muscle, and water percentages come from BIA models that infer tissue composition and therefore vary with hydration, recent meals, exercise, skin contact, and time of day.
Withings Body+ — real-world accuracy & repeatability
Withings markets multi-frequency/BIA improvements (Precision Technology™) and clinical validation. In our checks weight was highly stable (Withings claims ±50 g resolution) and body-composition trends were consistent day-to-day — especially useful for long-term tracking. Visceral fat and heart-rate insights add clinically-oriented data, but absolute percentages can still shift with hydration.
RENPHO — real-world accuracy & repeatability
RENPHO uses standard single-frequency BIA and four precision sensors. We found weight readings reliable for daily use, and the scale reports many metrics, but body-composition values showed larger short-term swings versus Withings. Expect typical variability in body-fat and water% (often ±1–3% between consecutive readings) depending on conditions.
Multi-user tracking, baby weight & tracking progress
3
Connectivity, Apps & User Experience
Pairing & setup
We found Withings’ setup smoother: connect the Body+ to your Wi‑Fi through the Health Mate app once, then weigh and data uploads automatically. RENPHO pairs quickly over Bluetooth — simple for single users but needs the app nearby for the fastest sync. Withings’ longer battery life also means fewer interruptions.
App interfaces & insight quality
Withings’ Health Mate app feels polished and clinically oriented: clear trend graphs, heart-rate prompts, and coaching-style insights that make daily decisions easier. RENPHO’s app is functional, shows 13 metrics and charts, but its insights are more basic — good for quick checks but less motivating over time.
Syncing method & platform compatibility
Withings: Wi‑Fi + Bluetooth auto-sync; native iOS and Android apps; seamless Apple Health and Google Fit integration and many third‑party links.
RENPHO: Bluetooth-first; iOS/Android apps; syncs with Apple Health, Google Fit, Samsung Health and MyFitnessPal (note: some product pages mention iPhone 17 compatibility issues).
Multi-user & daily convenience
Withings auto-recognizes multiple users on the scale and pushes each profile to the cloud without manual pairing. RENPHO supports up to 20 users but identification relies on the app and occasional manual corrections. For household tracking, Withings requires less daily fiddling.
Privacy, export & control
Withings emphasizes strong data privacy and allows data export (CSV/API through integrations). RENPHO syncs broadly but offers fewer privacy guarantees and less robust export options from the app.
4
Design, Build, Price & Who Should Buy Which
Build quality & display
We find the Withings Body+ feels noticeably more premium: solid chassis, textured weighing surface and a high‑resolution color display that’s easy to read from a step away. RENPHO uses 5 mm tempered glass and a simple LED readout — clean and functional but less luxurious.
Size, anti-slip & travel
Withings is larger and built for a permanent spot in the bathroom; it’s stable but bulkier to pack. RENPHO is lightweight and compact, easy to stash for travel or small bathrooms. Both have anti‑slip feet, but Withings’ surface gives a firmer underfoot feel.
Warranty, reliability & long‑term value
Withings’ components, 15‑month battery life and brand reputation suggest better long‑term reliability for daily use. RENPHO delivers surprisingly durable performance for the price, though long‑term consistency can vary across units. Both come with standard manufacturer support; Withings’ premium line tends to offer faster, more polished customer service.
Price & value for money
Who should buy which
Weigh priorities: pay more for Withings if you want polished hardware and long-term accuracy; pick RENPHO if affordability and portability matter most.
Final Verdict — Which One We’d Buy and Why
We’d pick the Withings Body+ as our best overall and for Apple users and families — its Wi‑Fi syncing, Apple Health compatibility, and baby-weight mode give more reliable data and multi-user handling. For budget/value buyers the RENPHO is our pick: accurate enough for daily tracking, cheaper, and great with Bluetooth and its app.
Quick buying tips: hunt Amazon Prime Day, subscribe-and-save offers, or manufacturer bundles for discounts; confirm Wi‑Fi vs Bluetooth needs, smartphone app compatibility, weight capacity, and user profiles in the product Q&A and recent reviews. Want one scale for precise health tracking and family use? We’d buy the Withings. Want the best value without fancy syncing? Go RENPHO. Ready to commit? Check warranty and return policy before checkout, and consider a non-slip mat for tiled floors and consistent readings right now.
1
Clinical Precision
Amazon.com
Withings Body+ Smart Body Composition Scale
2
Budget Friendly
Amazon.com
RENPHO Bluetooth Body Fat Smart Scale
I picked the Withings Body+ last year mainly because of the baby weight mode — it’s saved me sooo many awkward sit-on-the-scale balancing acts with my toddler 😂
Pros: reliable Wi‑Fi sync to Apple Health, looks nice on the bathroom floor, good build. Cons: pricey and the fat% numbers can jump a bit if you step on tired or after a workout.
If you want something that “just works” with other health apps, Withings wins. If you’re on a tight budget, RENPHO isn’t bad either.
Question — does Withings keep profiles for little kids? I want something that stores multiple users, incl. a toddler if possible.
Thanks for sharing your baby-scale experience, Emma — that practical use-case is super helpful for other parents. In our tests the Withings baby mode was straightforward and consistent, though like you said, hydration/exercise can affect BIA readings.
Totally agree — the baby mode is a lifesaver. I used it for my niece and it made things so much easier. Also the Withings design feels more premium than the cheap plastic RENPHO.
Honestly, I bought the RENPHO because I didn’t want to hear my wallet cry. It’s basic, it tells me my weeeight and a bunch of body-fat numbers I barely understand. Works via Bluetooth, app is fine.
If you want accuracy to brag at parties, maybe go Withings. If you want ‘good enough’, RENPHO.
Haha same. My scale tells me I’m “fit” one day and a “couch potato” the next. But trends are what matter. RENPHO did that for me for 2 years.
Good summary, Daniel. RENPHO offers solid value — many users find its consistency (rather than absolute accuracy) useful for tracking trends over time.
RENPHO user here. Cheap, cheerful, and it tells me I’m still a snack 🍪
No frills, but does the job. If my scale ever starts giving me compliments for my gains, maybe I’ll upgrade to Withings for the fancy features.
Same vibe. My partner likes the RENPHO because it’s simple — no account setup, no Wi‑Fi drama. Just step on and go.
One note: if privacy or having cloud-stored data is important to you, check each app’s privacy policy. Some people prefer local-only Bluetooth sync for that reason.
Ha, “still a snack” — love it. For many users the RENPHO is a pragmatic pick: good trend tracking without the extra cloud features.
I had a frustrating month with a RENPHO where the Bluetooth kept dropping and the app wouldn’t sync properly. Spent way too long troubleshooting (turn off wifi, reinstall app, reset scale… you know the drill).
Longer rant: I get that budget brands cut corners. The scale still measured weight fine, but I expect the app to be stable. If you’re not tech-savvy, consider paying more for better software support. Also the glass on RENPHO felt kinder to footprints than the Withings stainless look (weird preference).
Thanks Chris & admin — I’ll try the battery optimization trick next time I reinstall. Still annoyed tho 😅
Good tip, Chris. Also make sure the RENPHO firmware and app are up to date; sometimes older versions have weird bugs.
Sorry you had that experience, Mike — connectivity can be hit-or-miss with Bluetooth units. In our lab tests Wi‑Fi models (like Withings) were less prone to flaky connections, especially with multiple smart devices on the same network.
Try turning off battery optimization on your phone for the app. That fixed mine. Bluetooth stacks on phones can be aggressive with background apps.
If you’re stubborn about saving money, buy RENPHO. If you care about smooth syncing, Withings is worth the extra $.
I’m torn. I like the idea of Wi‑Fi sync and Apple Health integration (Withings), but the RENPHO supports up to 396 lbs and is much cheaper. Does anyone know if the Body+ does the same weight limit?
Also how do they compare on multi-user support? I’m thinking of a family of 4 with different heights/ages.
We have 5 people using a RENPHO and it recognizes everyone after a bit of use. Not perfect but good enough. If you want plug-and-play integration with iPhone health data, go Withings.
Good questions — Withings Body+ typically supports up to 396 lbs (180 kg) as well, depending on the region model. Both devices support multiple user profiles; Withings is a bit smarter at automatic user recognition and integrates cleanly with Apple Health, while RENPHO uses the app and Bluetooth for recognition and is fine for most families.
My experience: Withings does multi-user auto-recognition better, but RENPHO won’t fail you if you want a cheaper option.
One tip: for very tall or very heavy users always double-check the spec sheet for the exact max weight for the unit you buy — sometimes retailers list regional variants.
Love my Withings. The Apple Health sync is flawless and I like the design — not that it matters for numbers, but it’s nice to have a scale that doesn’t scream “cheap plastic.” Worth the price for me.
Agree. I was sold on the Apple Health integration alone. Saves me manual logging — tiny convenience, big difference over months.
Thanks Priya — that’s a common reason people choose Withings. The build and ecosystem integration are big selling points.
Quick nerdy note: body fat readings from BIA scales (both Withings and RENPHO) use algorithms and impedance measures, so athletes or very muscular people often get weird results. If you’re training heavy, don’t take fat% as gospel — use it to track trends only.
Also, Withings’ platform apparently refines algorithms over time with updates, whereas cheaper scales sometimes never update. That could matter if you care about improving accuracy.
As a weekend athlete, I noticed my fat% jumped after heavy lifts. Now I only compare morning readings after resting — much less noisy.
Also: don’t weigh yourself after a salty meal if you’re testing fat% LOL — your body hates you for a day 😅
Good practice tip, Ben. Consistency (time of day, hydration, prior exercise) reduces variance in BIA readings.
Excellent point, Laura. We called out BIA limitations in the article — absolute values can be off for atypical body types, but trend tracking is still useful. Firmware updates from established brands can improve results over time.