Don't miss our holiday offer - up to 50% OFF!
Our Pick: Coop Home Goods vs Everlasting Comfort Pillow
Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click and purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us.
We pit Coop Home Goods’ adjustable loft against Everlasting Comfort’s memory foam to see which actually helps us wake up pain-free — and the winner surprised us.
Tired of waking up stiff? We compare two popular shredded memory foam pillows, Coop Home Goods and Everlasting Comfort, to help you pick the best fit for your sleep style, cooling needs, and budget so you decide quickly, confidently today.
Highly Adjustable
Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow Queen
Amazon.com
We find this pillow delivers excellent customizability and long-term support. It suits a wide range of sleepers thanks to its adjustable fill and breathable cover, though it is pricier and may have a noticeable initial smell for some users.
Cooling Budget
Everlasting Comfort Shredded Memory Foam Pillow King
Amazon.com
We think this pillow offers strong adjustability and a cooling cover at a very attractive price. It’s a practical choice for users who want customizable loft, though some buyers report long-term flattening or issues with the included cooling case.
Coop Original Pillow
Everlasting Shredded Pillow
Coop Original Pillow
Everlasting Shredded Pillow
Coop Original Pillow
Everlasting Shredded Pillow
1
Design & Materials: What’s Inside Each Pillow
We break down construction, fill type, cover fabrics, and special features. For Coop Home Goods we highlight cross-cut adjustable memory foam and certifications; for Everlasting Comfort we note shredded foam, the Japanese cooling fiber case, and hypoallergenic claims. This helps us understand baseline comfort and care.
Coop Home Goods — Cross‑Cut Adjustable Memory Foam
Coop uses a cross-cut memory foam + microfiber blend that’s meant to be reshaped and removed until the loft suits you. The outer cover is their Lulltra fabric (soft, breathable) and the pillow ships with extra fill for fine‑tuning. Coop emphasizes fresh, never‑recycled foam and lists CertiPUR‑US and GREENGUARD Gold certifications.
Everlasting Comfort — Shredded Foam + Japanese Cooling Fiber Case
Everlasting Comfort is built around loose shredded memory foam that you can add/remove for loft. They include a Japanese cooling fiber pillowcase (claims a higher qmax cooling score) and use multiple zippered layers — inner liner plus outer covers — aiming for hygiene and easy washing. The brand promotes hypoallergenic materials.
2
Comfort & Sleep Performance: How They Feel Night After Night
We evaluate loft, firmness, adjustability, responsiveness, and cooling in real-use scenarios for side, back, and stomach sleepers, and compare neck alignment, pressure relief, edge behavior, and heat handling so you know which pillow performs best nightly.
Loft & Firmness
The Coop Original ships with a true medium‑firm baseline and extra fill so we can dial loft precisely. With fill added it holds a higher profile for side sleepers; remove fill and it compresses to flatter support for stomach sleepers. It keeps shape well over several nights.
Everlasting Comfort reads softer out of the bag. The shredded fill lets us pack a lot of loft for side sleeping, but it’s easier to compress and sometimes needs more frequent fluffing to maintain height for back or stomach sleeping.
Adjustability & Responsiveness
We find both adjustable, but feel different: Coop’s cross‑cut blend reshapes and rebounds more consistently, giving predictable contouring. Everlasting’s loose shredded foam is highly moldable but can clump; it’s simpler to squeeze into a shape but less springy.
Support & Neck Alignment
For side sleepers seeking consistent cervical support, Coop delivers better long‑term alignment once dialed. Back sleepers get balanced support from Coop and Everlasting if the latter is fully fluffed. Stomach sleepers prefer Coop with most fill removed; Everlasting can be too lofty unless you remove foam.
Pressure Relief & Edge Behavior
Coop contours to pressure points and resists edge collapse. Everlasting provides soft pressure relief initially but can flatten at the shoulder/edge over time, reducing support for heavier sleepers.
Cooling & Airflow
Coop’s Lulltra cover and cross‑cut foam improve airflow, though dense foam still traps some heat. Everlasting’s Japanese cooling fiber case feels cooler to the touch and helps surface temperature, but shredded foam can retain heat when densely packed.
3
Durability, Care & Safety: Longevity and Maintenance
We assess expected lifespan, resilience of shredded foam, flattening over time, and how easy each pillow is to wash or spot-clean. We also cover safety certifications (CertiPUR‑US, GREENGUARD Gold), hypoallergenic claims, warranty length, and practical care tips to extend pillow life.
Expected lifespan & resilience
Coop’s cross‑cut memory foam blend holds loft longer and resists permanent flattening better than loose shredded foam. Expect roughly 3–5 years of reliable support with regular fluffing and adjustment.
Everlasting Comfort’s shredded foam is very moldable but is more prone to compression and clumping; a realistic lifespan is about 2–4 years depending on how often you re‑fluff and remove/replace fill.
Washing, drying & routine care
Both pillows come with removable, machine‑washable covers. The inner fill on both can be refreshed, but we recommend spot‑cleaning or airing the shredded foam rather than frequent machine washes to avoid clumping or damage. Always dry completely before reassembling.
Safety, hypoallergenic claims & warranty
Coop is CertiPUR‑US and GREENGUARD Gold certified — that’s independent testing for low emissions and safe foam. Everlasting markets its pillow as hypoallergenic and adds zippered inner covers to protect fill, but it doesn’t list the same third‑party foam certifications on the product page. Warranty terms vary by seller and change over time; check the current Amazon listing for up‑to‑date coverage and return/trial policies before buying.
4
Price, Value & Buying Guide: Which Pillow Suits You Best
Price snapshot & sizing
We looked at the Amazon listings: the Coop Home Goods Original (Queen) runs around $68, while the Everlasting Comfort (King) is roughly $40. Our comparison uses those sizes/prices — check the product page for alternate sizes and current discounts.
Included extras & immediate value
Who should pick Coop Home Goods
We recommend Coop if you:
Who should pick Everlasting Comfort
We recommend Everlasting if you:
Quick buying tips
Feature Comparison Chart
Coop Original Pillow vs. Everlasting Shredded Pillow
VS
Price
$$$
VS
$$
Size Options
Queen (this listing) — other sizes available
VS
King (this listing) — other sizes available
Fill Material
Cross-cut memory foam & microfiber blend (fresh foam)
VS
Shredded memory foam (fresh foam)
Cover Material
Lulltra fabric (60% Polyester, 40% Viscose Rayon)
VS
Rayon derived from bamboo + Japanese cooling fiber case
Adjustability
Zippered inner pillow with extra fill bag included
VS
Zippered layers with extra fill bag included
Certifications
CertiPUR-US, GREENGUARD Gold
VS
No major third‑party certifications listed
Cooling Technology
Breathable cover and open shredded/cross-cut fill for airflow
VS
Japanese cooling fiber case claimed to be cooler than cotton
Firmness
Medium (customizable)
VS
Soft to medium (customizable by adding/removing fill)
Machine Washable
Removable cover machine washable; inner pillow spot clean
VS
Removable cases machine washable; inner fill kept separate
Loft / Thickness
Approx. 8 inches (adjustable by removing/adding fill)
VS
User-adjustable loft (dimensions: 36″ x 20″ for king)
Weight
3.5 pounds (queen listed)
VS
Light (packaged compressed; product listing shows low oz weight)
Return / Warranty
Generous return policy (manufacturer-backed), check retailer
VS
Seller offers lifetime replacement / strong customer support claims
Included Extras
Extra fill bag included
VS
Extra fill bag and cooling pillowcase included
Best For
Side, back, and stomach sleepers seeking custom support
VS
Budget-conscious sleepers who want adjustable cooling support
Final Verdict: Our Pick
We pick the Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow as our winner for most sleepers for its adjustable loft, certified materials, and balanced cooling-support. We still recommend Everlasting Comfort for budget-conscious shoppers who want a plush feel and a cooling case.
Ready to upgrade your sleep? Shop our top pick.
1
Highly Adjustable
Amazon.com
Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow Queen
2
Cooling Budget
Amazon.com
Everlasting Comfort Shredded Memory Foam Pillow King
Tried both of these and here’s my 2¢ after a month of sleeping on each:
– Coop (queen) = love the adjustable fill. Took out a handful of foam and it actually fixed my neck pain.
– Everlasting (king) = the cooling cover is legit but it felt WAY taller than my old pillow (had to fold it).
Also, FYI the Coop had a mild foam smell for 24–48 hrs. Nothing dramatic, but open a window if you’re sensitive. Overall: Coop for adjustability, Everlasting if you want a cool, plush feel. 😊
Thanks for the hands-on report, Olivia — really helpful. We noted the size/loft differences in the piece; for anyone swapping sizes, check dimensions before ordering (king vs queen can change feel a lot).
Totally agree about the smell — I left mine on the balcony for a day and it was fine. Good tip about removing foam from Coop, I did that and it fixed my shoulder pressure.
Small thing: if the Everlasting feels too tall, unzip and pull some shredded foam into a tote or spare pillowcase. Works like a charm and you can always add back.
Curious — did you wash the Everlasting’s Japanese cooling cover? Mine shrank a bit in the dryer, so I air-dry now.
Returned the Coop after a week — personal preference, not a knock. Felt too ‘processed’ for me? The Everlasting’s cooling cover won me over. Also pro tip: if you sleep hot, get a pillow protector under the cover; keeps things fresher.
Quick note: I’m a side sleeper and prefer firmer support. Coop felt a bit squishy after a few months, kinda compacted. Everlasting kept loft better for me, but it’s a KING size so it dominated my pillowcase lol. Both decent, depends on how much fluff you want.
Good point — long-term loft retention can vary. We mention in the article that shredded foam tends to redistribute while solid memory foam can compact; rotating/reshaping helps extend life.
Okay storytime: I ordered Coop because of the rave reviews, then my girlfriend said “we need the king” and bought Everlasting. So for the past month I’ve been pillow-hopping like a weirdo.
– Coop: adjustable is GREAT, but the foam bits can be annoying to wrestle when you’re trying to get it JUST right at 11pm. Nice for back sleepers.
– Everlasting: cooling fabric actually helped with my night sweats. Side sleepers take note — it’s loftier, which is good unless you’re small-framed.
Also: both had a bit of off-gassing the first night. Not terrible but noticeable. Worth the tweak if you’re picky. 😂
I’m small-framed and the Everlasting was too tall for me too. Ended up folding it in half for a week while waiting for a smaller one.
Off-gassing was worse for me on the Coop. Open a window and maybe let it decompress in another room for a day.
Thanks for the anecdote — stories like this are exactly why we compared both. Small adjustments (removing fill, folding, using a thinner pillowcase) can make a big difference in comfort.
Haha same pillow-hopping situation over here. Tom — try doing a quick toss-and-fluff in the dryer for 10 mins on low (no heat) to speed up airing out.
For anyone worried about wrestling foam — Coop’s zip system is a bit fiddly at first but once you get the hang of it it’s fine. Keep a trash bag handy for the excess bits 😅
Tom, your girlfriend sounds like mine — she always upgrades my life without asking. Also, dryer trick worked for me too (no heat).
Thinking about these two and I sleep HOT. The article says Everlasting is “2X better cooling” — is that marketing or real? Also, does Coop breathe enough if you remove some foam? Looking for facts + real hot-sleeper opinions. 🌡️
Good question — the “2X better” comes from the brand’s testing vs standard memory foam, mostly due to the Japanese cooling fiber cover and shredded structure that allows airflow. Real-world: many hot sleepers we surveyed found Everlasting cooler, but Coop can be made cooler by reducing fill and using a breathable pillowcase.
I’m a hot sleeper — Everlasting helped me more than Coop. Also try a cooling pillowcase and avoid high-thread-count sheets; they trap heat.